When the past is gone, it is gone; no amount of imagery
can truly reconstruct it.
I travelled to
But that past had disappeared from view. I found myself
a stranger among classmates whom I hadn't even known during my college days.
The campus had changed—it's still pretty, of course, but it has suffered from
the “edifice complex,” that peculiar American condition where wealthy donors
raise buildings as much to promote education as to set their names in stone, or
marble. What once was a bucolic area was now filled with malls and a
bewildering maze of highways. There was a superficiality to the reunion
parties, the food wasn't very good—it never is on American campuses—and it
became quickly clear that the courteous young students who served as guides for
the occasion had little cognisance with the past I'd experienced, and even less
curiosity about it. They seemed eager to talk about themselves, and so I did
what I like to do best—ask questions.
I went to the United States in 1967 at a time of great
cultural upheaval over its involvement in the Vietnam War, which cost nearly
60,000 American lives—and those of a million Vietnamese—and maimed tens of
thousands of young soldiers on both sides, and altered forever the lives and
destinies of untold numbers of men, women and children in Indochina. In the
end, it was all for nothing—America lost that war, its only such defeat, and,
Vietnam still figures as a metaphor for how the best and brightest policymakers
of a wealthy nations can misread developing societies many thousands of miles
away.
Coming from the relative placidity of my native
Mumbai—then known as
It wasn't easy to acclimatise myself to a new country
that would eventually be my permanent home—although I would have had no way of
knowing it at the time—and it wasn't easy being at Brandeis University near
Boston, a campus of ambitious, politically hyperactive, and sexually
libertarian students and faculty. Much of my time was spent covering the huge
war protests in and around Boston for the campus newspaper, The Justice—named
after the man in whose honour my nonsectarian university had been established
in 1948, Louis D. Brandeis, an associate justice of the United States Supreme
Court, a great legal scholar. Little wonder that my newspaper articles sparkled
more than my grades.
But that was where my professional life as a journalist
began. I went on to be a foreign correspondent at The New York Times, then at
Newsweek International and Forbes, and later as a producer of documentaries for
public television, an author of 14 books, and as the founder and editor of The
Earth Times, a newspaper on the environment and sustainable development. I
don't mean to seem facetious, but I am what I am because I skipped those
stimulating classes at Brandeis and opted to attend antiwar rallies and write about
them for The Justice. This also offered ample opportunities to meet women whose
personal and political passions nicely intertwined.
I looked for some of those women at my class reunion,
but none was there. There were those with whom I hadn't enjoyed liaisons, but I
could scarcely recognise. The years hadn't been biologically kind to most of
those who attended. Many of my classmates—both women and men—had gone on to
great distinction in fields as varied as the law, the sciences, medicine, the
theatre, and academe, of course. We took a lot of pictures, some with cameras,
most with our eyes. It will be the last such album that I will preserve.
That's because when the past is gone, it is gone; no
amount of imagery can truly reconstruct it. Before I made the journey of 10,000
kilometres from my current home in
There is no way that I can translate my regret into
something more meaningful. My past was lived in a different time, and although
it will linger on in my mind I don't think that I will revisit it through
another punishing physical journey. With every word I write, that past recedes,
it moves away beyond my grasp. Perhaps just as well.
Pranay Gupte is a veteran international journalist and
author. His next book, on
http://www.hindu.com/2010/06/18/stories/2010061855251300.htm