I would like to slightly change the first four lines of my comments. Raman Reddy's 'In Defence of the "Extracts from the Lives of Sri Aurobindo by Peter Heehs"' is one of the most rational analysis and precise interpretation of the extracts that were circulated in order to prove what Peter Heehs has written in the Lives of Sri Aurobindo. They are absolutely true and faithful to what he wrote in the book, for they are after all his own words. Mr. Reddy has wonderfully pointed out the extracts corrected by Peter Heehs made no substantial difference to the basic impression of Sri Aurobindo's denigration that the reader gets after reading them. Anurag Banerjee